Tuesday, November 16, 2021

parA and aparA

The MundakOpanishath urges all truth seekers to know two vidyas - ParA and aparA. 

aparA refers to Dharma, the source of which is the four Vedas along with their anga and upAngas, that helps to purify the sAdhaka. parA referes to Supreme unconditional Bhakti that helps to attain the Supreme imperishable Brahman. 

aparA is generally interpreted as the lower and parA as the higher. But aparA can also mean 'that which is another or alter'. So it is another or alternate form of parA only. AparA and parA can also stand for the pravrutti and Nivrutti aspects of Dharma. AparA may stand for Shiva tattva and parA for Vishnu tattva. 

The teaching that both needs to be known proves the importance of both and so they form one single whole.

aparA as dharma or parArtha karma is the front end of Bhakti or pure love. When there is pure love, there is selfless service and vice versa. When the whole universe is realized as the manifestation of the supreme Brahman, then whatever the yogi or sadhaka does, to serve the world or himself, ends up as a service to Brahman. Ultimately it results in a continuous dharmic / selfless activity. 

When the parA bhakti reaches extreme it may result in sheer silence or inactivity. Probably this is the Advaitic / Naishkarmya - the state of non-doing! or endless doing? It is said that all doubts are cleared at that stage Or there are no doubts at all!  

Unconditional Bhakti and experience of the Supreme Brahman is an endless act or an end in itself. The knower alone knows that ultimate state and that cannot be described in words. 

Namaste

Suresh

Tuesday, August 3, 2021

Atman and Brahman

 Advaita teaches that Atman/Self = subject = Brahman = True. 

anAtma = Object = Jagat = not True = appears to be true = illusion.

Ultimately Atmatva, Shivatva and even Advaitatva needs to be transcended as they point to qualities, to attain the unknowable / unthinkable nirguna, nirvishesha Brahman


Dvaita teaches that jIvAtman is not Brahman. In moksha the jiva attains it's own brahmatva or fullness / similar to parabrahman Vishnu.

Ishwara = Vishnu = Brahman = svatantra = independent truth.

Jiva = Atman = Infinite varieties = Paratantra = dependent truth (on Brahman).

Jada = Jagat = anAtma = Infinite varieties = Paratantra = dependent truth (on Brahman).


Interestingly Advaita and Dvaita are both based on the absolute nature of Atman/Brahman and the world of jiva/jada as AbhAsa/pratibimba/reflection of Brahman.

According to Advaita, the world is unreal because it is a reflection of the Atman/Brahman which is the original. But it also accepts that Atman/Brahman is the adhishTAna or the support for the jagat as a reflection. Just like the rope is the support or ground for the superimposed snake on the same. Jiva (as the self identified with the body) has no identification apart from the body which is the upAdhi. So when the upAdhi of body, which is a product of karma is gone the jiva merges with Brahman just like the space in the pot merges with the outer space or the reflection merges with the original. This merger is only apparent as it is already that.

But Dvaita argues that the world of multiplicity, as a reflection or dependent entity is dependently real,  as the jIva/Atma, as the upAdhi or medium is always real. The Jiva/Atma himself is a pratibimba or reflection of Brahman who is the original or Bimba. The jiva/Atma svaroopa is the upAdhi or medium also, like a mirror, in which Brahman is reflected as the antaryAmi. Every jiva has a svaroopa deha. So jiva svaroopa in Dvaita is essentially the body, in which Brahman is reflected. This makes it similar to Advaita with the only difference that the jiva svaroopa/body is dependently real.

V.Advaita teaches that Atman/chit and AnAtman/Achit and Brahman/nArAyaNa are different and real, but inseparably one like the body and soul. Identification of Atman/AnAtman culminates in Brahman just like identification of body like deva, man, women, human, animal and so on culminates in the indwelling soul.

Interestingly the body can also be taken as a reflection of the Atman/Brahman as the Self -  as it has properties that is opposed to the Atman. So this is compatible with Advaita and Dvaita where the world is taken to be vivarta / pratibimba respectively.


Atman and Brahman are two different words and so obviously with different meanings. So there cannot be any equation between them. But vedas teach the oneness of everything (sarvam) with Brahman and also the oneness of Atman (Self) with Brahman. 

This equation or identification between the two different words with different meanings is done based on the rule called sAmAnAdhikaraNyam in Sanskrit.

Advaita uses - bAdhAyAm sAmAnAdhikaraNyam where the attributes of jiva/embodied self and Ishwara/universal Self are removed to arrive at the pure impersonal conscious Self that is common between them.

V.Advaita uses - (Atma-Shareera) sAmAnAdhikaraNyam where Brahman alone is identified through all the many jiva and jada entities. 

Dvaita identifies every jiva/Atman and jada/anAtman and Ishwara Vishnu, separately. So all identifications are direct and so no sAmAnAdhikaraNyam is used. But still, Brahman is accepted to be known through every name/form - sarvanAma vAchya and sarvarUpavEdya. Also as Brahman is everywhere and indwelling in all as the antaryAmi - inner self, identification of every particular jiva/jada/name/form must culminate in Brahman who is everywhere. 

So for all practical purposes as long as one is embodied, the relation of Self and body between Brahman and the world must be valid in all views.

Reconciliation:

Every word has a meaning. Atman is a word with a meaning. So also is Brahman. Atman means the self. It is identified with whatever name/form it takes. If the jiva/self is in a stone it is a stone. If it is an animal's body it is an animal. In a human body it is human and in a devata's body it is a devata.

These identification keep changing depending on the body but atman is unchanging. Brahman is that which is everywhere, infinite. So, Atman whether it is embodied or not will always be in Brahman. Therefore it can be identified WITH Brahman at any point of time. It should be noted here that it is NOT Brahman also because the word and meaning are different. Atman is limited by anAtman and vice versa. But Brahman is unlimited or bhUmA and is everywhere. So the Vedic scripture declares Everything is Brahman - Sarvam khalvidam Brahma and this Atma is Brahma - ayamAtma Brahma.

Atman and anAtma are opposed to each other. But Brahman is un-opposed as all opposites are cognized in it. So it is essentially the sarvAtmA - the Self of all or paramAtmA which is in the Atman as well as in anAtma/prakriti. The jiva/Atma has to recognize and exist in this sarvAtma Brahman. Only then it will be a brahmachAri - brahmaNi charati - one who exists/moves in Brahman. In other words, the Self should expand beyond the body to include everything. Only then it becomes truely selfless bigger self or mahAtmA.

The Brahman that is indwelling in the Atman is the supreme AtmA - paramAtma. The same Brahman that is in prakriti / everything, takes the name Sarva. When that universal AtmA is identified everything is identified at once.

It should be noted that in Advaita, identity is only based on the lakshyArtha - indicative truth. Difference in literal truth or vAchyArtha is accepted though it comes under mithya or vyavahAra. So tattvamasi (you are that) and " atattvamasi / tvamtadadheenosi" (you are not that and you are dependent on that) both gets satisfied from the point of view of the embodied jivAtman.

Tatvamasi helps to identify  - nirguna brahman - the unknowable. Atattvamasi helps to establish the difference between saguna brahman and jiva - vAchyArtha - literal truth - leading to elimination of asura bhAva or I am God mentality. 

Objection:

This creates two Brahman with opposite qualities (one in the Atman as nirguna ) and the other in anAtma prakriti as saguna. 

Answer: Yes, but still that is not a problem. Brahman that is in the Atman is Truth/jnAna/Amrutha and Brahman that is in anAtma / jagat / prakriti / everything is Mruthyu / Dharma which is its own glory. Jiva or the entity going through pleasure and pain is stuck between these two forms of Brahman. When the jiva engages in dharma which is nothing but selfless service to the Brahman manifesting as jagat then both forms of Brahman gets aligned and there will be limitless Ananda. On the other hand when the jiva due to identification with the limited body acts in a selfish manner then the One Brahman gets divided into jnAna and agnAna leading to endless binding in pleasure and pain (sukha and duhkha in samsara).

The essence of sanAtana dharma is to continuously unite the Atman/Purusha with paramAtman who pervades anAtma/Prakrithi. This is nothing but continuous identification of the Self (Atman) with Everything (Sarva). Only then total selflessness or Brahmatva can arise. As Brahman is ananta or endless, Moksha or attainment of Brahman is a endless tapasya. That is why Ishwara who is nitya mukta is always shown to be engaged in tapasya.

Here is another food for thought:

Atman becomes Brahman / unlimited, only when one does not see any difference between oneself and everything else. Everything is in the Atman and the Atman is in everything. This is true Advaita where there will be no difference between nirguna Atma roopi Brahman and saguna Vishwa/Sarva roopi Brahman!

Namaste

Suresh


Saturday, June 12, 2021

SrimadbhAgavatam in support of Advaita, Dvaita and VishishtAdvaita

Namaste,

SrimadbhAgavatam is very well known as a Vaishnava purANa. 

Vaishnavas in general do not subscribe to the Advaita philosophy which teaches the oneness of jIvAtma with paramAtma or Brahman and the world of variety as mithya or illusion. 

But there are many slokas in the supposedly vaishnava purANa of SrimadbhAgavatam, that directly or indirectly supports Advaita. Probably that is the reason why majority of commentaries on this purAna are from Advaita AchAryAs.

Here is a humble attempt to compile slokas from SrimadbhAgavatam that implicitly or explicitly supports Advaita:

व्रतं स आस्थितो मौनं आत्मैकशरणो मुनिः ।

निःसङ्गो व्यचरत् क्षोणीं अनग्निरनिकेतनः ॥ 3-24-42 ॥

मन्यमान इदं विश्वं मायारचितमात्मनि ।
अविद्यारचितस्वप्न गन्धर्वनगरोपमम् ॥ 4-12-15 ॥ 

सुप्तिप्रबोधयोः सन्धावात्मनो गतिमात्मदृक्
पश्यन्बन्धं च मोक्षं च मायामात्रं न वस्तुतः || 7-13-5 ||

यस्मिन्निदं विरचितं व्योम्नीव जलदावलिः ।
 नानेव भाति नाभाति स्वप्नमायामनोरथः ॥ 9-18-49 ॥

तद्ब्रह्म परमं सूक्ष्मं चिन्मात्रं सदनन्तकम्
विज्ञायात्मतया धीरः संसारात्परिमुच्यते ||10-88-10||

 भयं द्वितीयाभिनिवेशतः स्यात्
     ईशात् अपेतस्य विपर्ययोऽस्मृतिः ।
 तन्माययातो बुध आभजेत्तं
     भक्त्यैकयेशं गुरुदेवतात्मा ॥ 11-2-37 ॥
 अविद्यमानोऽप्यवभाति हि द्वयोः
     ध्यातुर्धिया स्वप्नमनोरथौ यथा ।
 तत्कर्मसङ्कल्पविकल्पकं मनो
     बुधो निरुंध्याद् अभयं ततः स्यात् ॥ 11-2-38 ॥

श्रीभगवानुवाच
( अनुष्टुप् )
बद्धो मुक्त इति व्याख्या गुणतो मे न वस्तुतः
गुणस्य मायामूलत्वान्न मे मोक्षो न बन्धनम् ||11-11-1||
शोकमोहौ सुखं दुःखं देहापत्तिश्च मायया
स्वप्नो यथात्मनः ख्यातिः संसृतिर्न तु वास्तवी ||11-11-2||

आत्मानमन्यं च स वेद विद्वानपिप्पलादो न तु पिप्पलादः
योऽविद्यया युक्स तु नित्यबद्धो विद्यामयो यः स तु नित्यमुक्तः ||11-11-7||

वैशारद्येक्षयासङ्ग शितया छिन्नसंशयः
प्रतिबुद्ध इव स्वप्नान्नानात्वाद्विनिवर्तते ||11-11-12||

 विविक्तक्षेमशरणो मद्‍भावविमलाशयः ।
 आत्मानं चिन्तयेदेकमभेदेन मया मुनिः ॥ 11-18-21 ॥
 अन्वीक्षेतात्मनो बन्धं मोक्षं च ज्ञाननिष्ठया ।
 बन्ध इन्द्रियविक्षेपो मोक्ष एषां च संयमः ॥ 11-18-22 ॥

यदेतदात्मनि जगन् मनो-वाक्-प्राण-संहतम् ।
 सर्वं मायेति तर्केण स्वस्थः त्यक्त्वा न तत्स्मरेत् ॥ 11-18-27 ॥

एक एव परो ह्यात्मा भूतेष्वात्मन्यवस्थितः ।
 यथेदमुदपात्रेषु भूतान्येकात्मकानि च ॥ 11-18-32 ॥

पुरुषेश्वरयोरत्र न वैलक्षण्यमण्वपि
तदन्यकल्पनापार्था ज्ञानं च प्रकृतेर्गुणः ||11-22-11||

स्वप्ने यथा शिरश्छेदं पञ्चत्वाद्यात्मनः स्वयम् ।
 यस्मात्पश्यति देहस्य तत आत्मा ह्यजोऽमरः ॥ 12-5-4 ॥
 घटे भिन्ने घटाकाश आकाशः स्याद् यथा पुरा ।
 एवं देहे मृते जीवो ब्रह्म सम्पद्यते पुनः ॥ 12-5-5 ॥

सर्ववेदान्तसारं यद् ब्रह्मात्मैकत्वलक्षणम् ।
 वस्तु अद्वितीयं तन्निष्ठं कैवल्यैकप्रयोजनम् ॥ 12-13-12 ॥

The following supports both Advaita and V.Advaita:

वस्तुतो जानतामत्र कृष्णं स्थास्नु चरिष्णु च ।
 भगवद् रूपमखिलं नान्यद् वस्त्विह किञ्चन ॥ 10-14-56 ॥

एक एव परो ह्यात्मा सर्वेषामपि देहिनाम्
नानेव गृह्यते मूढैर्यथा ज्योतिर्यथा नभः |10-55-44|

यस् आत्मकमिदं विश्वं क्रतवश्च यदात्मकाः ।

अग्निराहुतयो मंत्राः साङ्ख्यं योगश्च यत्परः ॥ 10-74-20 ॥


 एक एवाद्‌वितीयोऽसौ अवैतदात्म्यमिदं जगत् ।
 आत्मनात्माश्रयः सभ्याः सृजत्यवति हन्त्यजः ॥ 10-74-21 ॥

आत्मा ह्येकः स्वयंज्योतिर्नित्योऽन्यो निर्गुणो गुणैः
आत्मसृष्टैस्तत्कृतेषु भूतेषु बहुधेयते ||10-85-34||
खं वायुर्ज्योतिरापो भूस्तत्कृतेषु यथाशयम्
आविस्तिरोऽल्पभूर्येको नानात्वं यात्यसावपि ||10-85-35||

परे ब्रह्मणि चात्मानं परं ब्रह्म तथात्मनि ।

वीक्षमाणो विहायेक्षां अस्माद् उपरराम ह ॥ 4-28-42 ॥ 

तस्माद्युक्तेन्द्रियग्रामो युक्तचित्त इदं जगत्
आत्मनीक्षस्व विततमात्मानं मय्यधीश्वरे ||11-7-9||


ज्ञानविज्ञानसंयुक्त आत्मभूतः शरीरिणाम्
अत्मानुभवतुष्टात्मा नान्तरायैर्विहन्यसे  ||11-7-10||

सर्वभूतसुहृच्छान्तो ज्ञानविज्ञाननिश्चयः
पश्यन्मदात्मकं विश्वं न विपद्येत वै पुनः ||11-7-12||

सत्यस्य ते स्वदृश आत्मन आत्मनोऽन्यं
वक्तारमीश विबुधेष्वपि नानुचक्षे
सर्वे विमोहितधियस्तव माययेमे
ब्रह्मादयस्तनुभृतो बहिरर्थभावाः ||11-7-17||

अहमात्मान्तरो बाह्योऽनावृतः सर्वदेहिनाम्
यथा भूतानि भूतेषु बहिरन्तः स्वयं तथा ||11-15-36||


The following supports Dvaita:

त्रिगुणत्वात्कर्तुः श्रद्धया कर्मगतयः पृथग्विधाः 

सर्वा एव सर्वस्य तारतम्येन भवन्ति ॥ 5-26-2 ॥ 


यत्कर्मभिर्यत्तपसा ज्ञानवैराग्यतश्च यत् ।
 योगेन दानधर्मेण श्रेयोभिः इतरैरपि ॥ 11-12-32 ॥


 सर्वं मद्‍भक्तियोगेन मद्‍भक्तो लभतेऽञ्जसा ।
 स्वर्गापवर्गं मद्धाम कथञ्चिद् यदि वाञ्छति ॥ 11-12-33 ॥


The following supports V.Advaita and Dvaita too:


धारयिष्यति ते वेगं रुद्रस्त्वात्मा शरीरिणाम् ।
 यस्मिन् ओतं इदं प्रोतं विश्वं शाटीव तन्तुषु ॥ 9-9-8 ॥

मामेकमेव शरणमात्मानं सर्वदेहिनाम्
याहि सर्वात्मभावेन मया स्या ह्यकुतोभयः ||11-12-15||

भूम्यम्ब्वग्न्यनिलाकाशा भूतानां पञ्चधातवः
आब्रह्मस्थावरादीनां शारीरा आत्मसंयुताः ||11-21-5||

परस्वभावकर्माणि न प्रशंसेन्न गहयेत् ।
 विश्वमेकात्मकं पश्यन् प्रकृत्या पुरुषेण च ॥ 11-28-1 ॥



The following supports all views:

ओं नमस्तेऽस्तु भगवन्नारायण वासुदेवादिपुरुष महापुरुष महानुभाव परममङ्गल परमकल्याण परमकारुणिक केवल जगदाधार लोकैकनाथ सर्वेश्वर लक्ष्मीनाथ परमहंसपरिव्राजकैः परमेणात्मयोगसमाधिना परिभावितपरिस्फुटपारमहंस्यधर्मेणोद्घाटिततमःकपाटद्वारे चित्तेऽपावृत आत्मलोके स्वयमुपलब्धनिजसुखानुभवो भवान् ॥ 6-9-33॥


दुरवबोध इव तवायं विहारयोगो यदशरणोऽशरीर इदमनवेक्षितास्मत्समवाय आत्मनैवाविक्रियमाणेन सगुणमगुणः सृजसि पासि हरसि ॥ 6-9-34 ॥
अथ तत्र भवान् किं देवदत्तवदिह गुणविसर्गपतितः पारतन्त्र्येण स्वकृतकुशलाकुशलं फलमुपाददात्याहोस्विदात्माराम उपशमशीलः समञ्जसदर्शन उदास्त इति ह वाव न विदामः ॥ 6-9-35 ॥_*
न हि विरोध उभयं भगवत्यपरिमितगुणगण ईश्वरेऽनवगाह्यमाहात्म्येऽर्वाचीनविकल्पवितर्कविचारप्रमाणाभासकुतर्कशास्त्रकलिलान्तःकरणाश्रयदुरवग्रहवादिनां विवादानवसर उपरतसमस्तमायामये केवल एवात्ममायामन्तर्धाय को न्वर्थो दुर्घट इव भवति स्वरूपद्वयाभावात् ॥ 6-9-36 ॥
समविषममतीनां मतमनुसरसि यथा रज्जुखण्डः सर्पादिधियाम् ॥ 6-9-37 ॥_*
स एव हि पुनः सर्ववस्तुनि वस्तुस्वरूपः सर्वेश्वरः सकलजगत्कारणकारणभूतः सर्वप्रत्यगात्मत्वात्सर्वगुणाभासोपलक्षित एक एव पर्यवशेषितः ॥ 6-9-38 ॥

ततो हरौ भगवति भक्तिं कुरुत दानवाः
आत्मौपम्येन सर्वत्र सर्वभूतात्मनीश्वरे || 7-7-53 ||
दैतेया यक्षरक्षांसि स्त्रियः शूद्रा व्रजौकसः
खगा मृगाः पापजीवाः सन्ति ह्यच्युततां गताः || 7-7-54 ||
एतावानेव लोकेऽस्मिन्पुंसः स्वार्थः परः स्मृतः
एकान्तभक्तिर्गोविन्दे यत्सर्वत्र तदीक्षणम्  || 7-7-55 ||


Namaste

Suresh



Monday, March 29, 2021

Bhagavadgita - Hidden Secrets - 3

Namaste,


Now in this third adhyAya the importance of karma or action is sought.

Each soul is potentially divine said Swami Vivekananda. But the soul gets covered by the anAdi (beginning-less) karma. This coverage is the root cause for all the differences in the world. But these differences in the body and the related nature or guna or svabhAva is the basis for the divisions in varna and ashrama. This division is only in labor as all souls are of the nature of consciousness and bliss and therefore intrinsically equal.

The ideal of varna and ashrama dharma leads to co-operation as opposed to competition. It helps to build families and nurture diversity. When humans serve devatas through yagya, devatas will bring proper rains and harvest.

Performance of dharma or prescribed duties is the only way for attainment of Brahman. Dharma has two modes - pravrutti and Nivrutti. Pravrutti dharma is performance of one's own prescribed dharma. Though it varies based on one's Varna and ashrama it always ends up as a service to the Brahman manifesting as this very universe. Nivrutti dharma is withdrawal of ones' own senses and mind and meditating on Brahman situated as the antaryAmi paramAtma - supreme Self.

What prompts one to engage in adharma? BGita 3-36 explicitly states - it is one's own kama (lust or adhArmic desire) and krodha (anger). The only way to control this is to be in satsangha (company of good).

Performance of prescribed duty without any blind attachment to material benefit as a offering or yagya
to Ishwara manifesting as this universe, leads to perfection.


Secret 1:
Yagya is the basis of Vedic morality.

The Lord uses the words, "kuru" (do) and "May matam" (my view). Those are the ones that we need to pay extra attention to as it is the explicit command and view of the Lord.

The word Yagya refers to the act of sacrifice (verb) as well as the Lord himself (noun). Yagyo vai Vishnu says Veda - Yagya means verily Vishnu who is the paramAtma, the supreme Self that abides in all. This can be attained only through sattvic tyaga or sacrifice.

The following mantras capture the above points:

BGita 3-9:

यज्ञार्थात्कर्मणोऽन्यत्र लोकोऽयं कर्मबन्धनः ।
तदर्थं कर्म कौन्तेय मुक्तसङ्गः समाचर ॥ ९ ॥


yajnarthat karmano 'nyatra
loko 'yam karma-bandhanah
tad-artham karma kaunteya
mukta-sangah samacara


yajna-arthat—only for the sake of Yajna or God, ; karmanah—work done; anyatra—otherwise; lokah—world; ayam—this; karma-bandhanah—bondage by work; tat—Him; artham—for the sake of; karma—work; kaunteya—O son of Kunti; mukta-sangah—without attachment ; samacara—do it perfectly.


All actions need to be done as a sacrifice or worship onto God, otherwise action binds one to this material world. Therefore, O son of Kunti, perform your prescribed duties for the sake of God, and in that way you will always remain unattached and free from bondage.


B-Gita 3-11

देवान्भावयतानेन ते देवा भावयन्तु वः ।
परस्परं भावयन्तः श्रेयः परमवाप्स्यथ ॥ ११ ॥

istan bhogan hi vo deva
dasyante yajna-bhavitah
tair dattan apradayaibhyo
yo bhunkte stena eva sah


istan—desired; bhogan—necessities of life; hi—certainly; vah—unto you; devah—the demigods; dasyante—award; yajna-bhavitah—being satisfied by the performance of sacrifices; taih—by them; dattan—things given; apradaya—without offering; ebhyah—to the demigods; yah—he who; bhunkte—enjoys; stenah—thief; eva—certainly; sah—is he.


In charge of the various necessities of life, the demigods, being satisfied by the performance of yajna [sacrifice], supply all necessities to man. But he who enjoys these gifts, without offering them to the demigods in return, is certainly a thief.


B-Gita 3-30

मयि सर्वाणि कर्माणि संन्यस्याध्यात्मचेतसा ।
निराशीर्निर्ममो भूत्वा युध्यस्व विगतज्वरः ॥ ३० ॥

mayi sarvani karmani
sannyasyadhyatma-cetasa
nirasir nirmamo bhutva
yudhyasva vigata-jvarah


mayi—unto Me; sarvani—all sorts of; karmani—activities; sannyasya—giving up completely; adhyatma—with full knowledge of the self; cetasa—consciousness; nirasih—without desire for profit; nirmamah—without ownership; bhutva—so being; yudhyasva—fight; vigata-jvarah—without being lethargic.

Therefore, O Arjuna, surrendering all your works unto Me, with mind intent on Me, and without desire for gain and free from egoism and lethargy, fight.






Monday, January 4, 2021

Hindus and Others

There is no "other" for a true Hindu! Because according to the Vedic scripture, the Supreme God or Brahman is everywhere and from that spiritual point everything gets included and transcended. So a true Hindu will not divide the world as Hindu and non-Hindu.

On the other hand, all other non-Brahmic or A-Brahamic views, look upon every other view, including the "all-inclusive Hindu" view as the "other" and false also. This makes their view of reality exclusive or myopic or constricted resulting in artificial division and endless conflict. 

As the Hindu God Brahman, the absolute reality, is everywhere it always remains the origin/abode/destination of all kinds of views. Even though all kinds of partial views of non-Hindus are also rooted and indirectly pointing to the same universal reality, their myopic view is not encompassing or revealing the all pervasive nature of the absolute reality or God or Brahman.

So the difference or the conflict between Hindu and others is nothing but the conflict between whole and part. All other views are therefore partial, finite and incomplete as they are only looking at a part of the otherwise whole truth which is cognized by Hindus. 

As God is the all pervading universal absolute reality and also the source/abode/destination of all kinds of existence and views, there is a need for Hindus to show how all other "non-Hindu" views are indirectly pointing to the same Hindu reality or God. 

So let's examine the basic tenets of some major Abrahamic religions and see how they are indirectly teaching/endorsing Hindu view/God Brahman.

Hindu view of Christian teaching:

The name Jehova/Jesus could be a corrupted form of the Hindu/Vedic word Jiva/Isha. Every Jiva or the Atman/embodied self is the Isha or owner/controller of his/her body. This body is the cross on which the Jiva/Jesus is currently crucified as it were. He is crucified due to ignorance/attachment/identification of the self with the body, resulting in the endless cycle of birth/pleasure and death/pain. This Jiva needs to realize that it is imperishable and different from the perishable body. Every Jiva is also a son/servant of God, Brahman/ParamAtma/Supreme universal Self, who is everywhere, manifesting as this very Universe. This realization that the Jiva is not the body, but the son/servant/image of God, is the actual resurrection/rising from death/ignorance, that helps to lift the Jiva above all worldly dualities of pain/pleasure and utilize the body as a tool to serve the world. This unconditional selfless service or duty that is rendered by the Jiva onto the God / Brahman manifesting as the universe goes by the name of Dharma.

The Christian trinity of God/Father-Jesus/son-holy spirit, could also correspond to the Hindu trinity of ParamAtma (Supereme Self) - Jivatma (individual self) - Prakrithi/PrAna (energy of God) that unites them.

So Christian view is indirectly teaching and endorsing Hindu Dharma only.


Hindu view of Islam:

The one and only Islamic God, Allah is the corrupted form of the Hindu name AtmA. The Hindu supreme God Brahman is the all pervading and indwelling AtmA or the spirit Self of the entire universe. God Allah as the universal Self / Atman is obviously non-dual and so will always be non-dual or One without a second.

The name Muhammed PBUH, could be a corrupted form of the Hindu word mahAmodha (Greatest enjoyer) or mahAprAna (Great Vital breath prAna) that denotes Hanuman, who is the embodiment of knowledge/power/happiness and is the Guru or prophet that teaches the supreme God in the form of Rama (Rahim). This supreme God Rama who is actually the Atman / Brahman is indwelling in Hanuman, manifesting as the Vital breath or PrAna that enlivens all beings. This MahAprAna or the vital breath always remains as the connecting link between every embodied being/jiva and the universe/God. So the Islamic belief that Muhammed is the only perfect teacher of Allah or God is perfectly aligning with the Hindu teaching that Hanuman in the form of mahAprAna (vital breath) is the perfect teacher or even the indicator of God in the form of Atma, residing in all. The process of breathing is an indicator of the existence of God/Allah/Atma in any body. The body is existing and functioning only because of the existence of the Self/Atman. No one can deny this as it is experiential. This vAyuputra or mahAprAna is seen as the visible manifestation of God / pratyaksha Brahma. 

Our dependence for existence on the Hindu God manifesting as this entire universe cannot be denied by anyone. There is a need therefore for humans to return the favor by engaging in selfless service to all the many entities on which we depend, like the five elements (devatas), our fore-fathers, parents, teachers, society, the world of animals and so on. This self-less service is nothing but Dharma.

So all abrahAmic religions are unknowingly and indirectly teaching Hindu dharma only. But due to their ignorance of myopic view they love and serve people subscribing to their ideology which hating others who hold different views. But true Hindus on the other hand do not discriminate as they see all humans and entire creation as a manifestation of God only. 

Dharma as parArtha karma or self-less service is so experiential and universal, that no thinking and honest human can deny. Reality will always be the same, all encompassing and so there is a need to un-convert from all myopic views in order to fully grasp and appreciate it's universal/infinite nature.

Namaste,

Suresh

Friday, August 28, 2020

Tat Tvam Asi - a different interpretation

Namaste,


Tat Tvam Asi - "That You are" - is one of the most famous Vedic statement or mahA vAkya. The complete vedic sentence is Sa ya esho anima aitadatmyam idam sarvam, tat satyam, sa atmAtattvamasi, svetaketo, iti;.


In Advaita :

The mahA vAkya is split as  AtmA + tat + tvam + asi, Swetaketu = That Atma (all pervading Brahman) you are, Swetaketu. 

So the oneness of the individual self / jiva with Brahman is taught. 


In Dvaita:

It is split as AtmA + atat + tvam + asi, Swetaketu = That Atma (all pervading Brahman/Self) is NOT you, Swetaketu.

It is also interpreted as AtmA + tat + tvam (tad adheeno) + asi + Swetaketu.

Meaning:  Atma or the indwelling controller Spirit Self or God is THAT and you are subservient  to / controlled by THAT, Swetaketu. 

The above interpretations of Advaita and Dvaita appears to be opposed to each other and both are grammatically correct. It should be noted that in both traditions, the word 'tvam' refers to Swetaketu - the student, who is the embodied jiva. 

So which one is correct? The disagreement or contradiction seems to be never ending.


In V.Advaita:

It is split as AtmA + tat + tvam + asi = That Atma (all pervading Brahman/Self) you are.

The above split seems to be the same/similar to Advaita! But the difference is the word 'Tat' and 'tvam' both refers to Brahman established as the inner Self of the jagat and jiva respectively, as opposed to Advaita and Dvaita where tvam refers to the jiva only. Brahman that is pervading the universe is Tat and the same Brahman indwelling in the  body/jiva/Swetaketu is tvam. Jiva and Jada are in the form of body and identification of the body always culminates in the soul/self/Brahman. This identification of one entity through another entity is called sAmAnAdhikaraNyam - concomitant co-ordination. 

The difference and oneness in the form of body and soul/self is established here. This seems to reconcile / integrate the apparent difference between Advaita and Dvaita.

Here is some detailed analysis from the V. Advaita point of view:

Tat = Brahman as the universal Self pervading and supporting the universe as it's body

Tvam = Brahman indwelling in Swetaketu/jiva, pervading and supporting his body.

The meaning of AtmA + tat + tvam + asi + Swetaketu  is:

That Brahman which is the all pervading Atma/Spirit Self of the universe is the spirit Self of you, Swetaketu. Another way of saying the same thing is - "You are having THAT as your Atma, Swetaketu".

The identification of the body always culminates in the Soul. So the identification of Swetaketu is culminating in the all pervading Brahman. There is no separate identification of the jiva / jada apart from Brahman. 

The essential teaching is that Brahman which is the Atma / Spirit Self pervading / sustaining the entire universe is the spirit Self that is indwelling / sustaining / supporting the body/jiva/Swtaketu.

Brahman that abides in all as the inner Self is One or Advaita or non-dual. 

The identification of jada/Tat and jiva/tvam, identifies those particular entities and also culminating in Brahman that pervades both. This meaning of integral oneness of everything, seems to satisfies all views.

But an objection still remains!! :  

If the word tvam refers to the indwelling Brahman, then to whom the Veda is teaching? It cannot be teaching to Brahman ! The name Swetaketu refers to the jiva only and so it is obvious that the teaching is delivered to the jiva. So the word tvam must point to jiva/Swetaketu and not Brahman!

So how do we answer this objection? Or is there any other interpretation? Here is a humble attempt:

My personal view :

1) The word Tat refers to the VishwantaryAmi Brahman (pervading the universe), who is Vishnu. The word tvam refers to jivantaryAmi Brahman who is Rudra/Shiva. The inseparable oneness of these two deities is taught in this Vedic statements. Jiva and Brahman (Atma / paramAtma) are inseparably one and they exist in each other. There is no separate identification between the self and the universe. Every individual / Atman should remain / exist / move in Brahman which is everywhere. That is the literal meaning of Brahmacharya - remaining in Brahman. It is the constant location of oneself in Brahman who is everywhere which is an endless tapasya. This view may help to unite all view points. 

The following mantra which occurs in the Shatarudreeya supports the above claim and I think all Hindus from all traditions should be able to chant this mantra:

"Om namo bhagavate rudrAya visNave mrutyurme pAhi"


2) Tat = Universe = Everything = Vishesha = Sarveshwara = Saguna = Narayana 

    Tvam = Self = Non-dual = sAmAnya = Sarveshwareshwara = Nirguna = Shiva. 

Sri Adi ShankarAchArya also teaches umteen number of times, the oneness of Saguna and Nirguna Brahman, in his Brahma Sutra bhAshya. The oneness of Saguna and Nirguna simply means, sakala kalyani guna Brahman with no dosha or blemishes.


Here is another explanation:

One of the avatAra of Vishnu in the form Nara and Narayana is very much relevant here. Tat stands for Narayana (teacher) and tvam stands for nara (student). When the teacher is teaching tat tvam asi - he is identifying or realizing the nara roopi Brahman tvam in the form of the student. When the student repeats the mantra "tat tvam asi" he is realizing Narayana roopi Brahman in the form of his teacher. So the oneness or inseparable oneness of the teacher, taught and the teaching, continues as unbroken chain of teacher-student tradition or parampara which makes Dharma sanAtana.

Vedic Brahman is an entity that is commonly present in all and so is the greatest equalizer and unifier. So the viewpoints of Advaita, Dvaita and V.Advaita must be complimentary and not contradictory to each other.


Namaste

Suresh

Wednesday, July 22, 2020

Vedic God Exists

Yes, Vedic God exists and He alone exists!

The above may appear to be very arrogant claim. But that iss the reality
which is surely bitter for those who disagree.

Lets examine.

Vedic God, Brahman or paramAtma (ultimate Self) is identified as the
absolute universal Self that pervades and indwells in the universe
and the individual self. He is the only source/abode/destination of
all names/forms. Everything is arising/remaining/returning back to Him.

He is thus manifesting as the Self that is shining in all.
This Vedic God established as the inner Self of all beings cannot be
denied by anyone. This Self is the abode of sat/existence/truth,
chit/consciousness and ananda/bliss. As this God is auspicious He is
Shiva. As He is all pervading and indwelling in all, He is Vishnu.
All other gods cannot be external to this Supreme all-encompassing God.

As He is all pervading, He is the in-dweller of the object/prakriti
/matter and the in-dweller of the subject/jiva/self and the in-dweller
of the relationship in the form of universal Love that binds the subject/man/masculine and the object/prakriti/nature/women.

Obviously this Vedic God situated as the universal Self, is self-
established and refutes all other opposing viewpoints.

All other view points are either untruth or half truth and at best
could be only an approximation to this Vedic God.

Atheists will never be able to doubt or even deny their own self or
existence which is vitally related to the Self or existence of nature.
This essential Self is non-material and super natural, because it is
unchanging and self luminous. Everything else in the world of nature
/ matter, is changing. The Self as a witness of change cannot change.
Changing inert matter can never be the cause for the unchanging
conscious Self. If it is so, then matter becomes potentially conscious.
So Atheistic or the view of material causation falls either way.

Buddhists who ultimately deny everything have to deny their own view
point also. So it is Self-destructive. The denier of everything
cannot deny himself. So indirectly it points to the eternity of
the Self which is the Vedic view! That is why Buddha is considered
an incarnation of Vishnu in the Vedic scriptures whose main purpose
is to teach Vedic view in a negative way.

Believers in a God other than or external to this universal Self will
never be able to win the Athiests/sceptics. The fight between Abrahamic
religions and athiests is well known. It will always be endless because
truth is not complete on both sides. Abrahamic believers recognize only
the Fatherly aspect of existence/reality/God. While atheists recognize
only prakriti/nature or motherly aspect of existence/reality/God. But
the fact is Father or mother alone can never give birth to a child.
The seed alone or the earth alone can never produce a plant. They have
to come together for anything to get created. The subject and the object
have to come together in the process perception resulting in knowledge.

Believers invariably end up with a leap of faith. Non believers will
never be able to find lasting support for their morality. In order to have
proper basis for the golden rule of morality they have no choice but to
accept this Vedic God who is established as the inner Self of all and
manifesting as this very universe on which every being depends absolutely
for existence.

The entire universe is the personality of Vedic God and absolute dependence
on the same for existence cannot be denied by anyone. The individual self
exists in the universal Self/Vedic God and vice versa.

This is the essence of all Vedic teaching and the supreme truth!

Namaste
Suresh

Sunday, May 17, 2020

Bhagavad Gita - Hidden Secrets - 2

Bhagavad Gita - Second Chapter - jnAna yoga


Despondency is a disease. The cause for that is ignorance. Unfortunately Arjuna, the great warrior himself is infested. How about ordinary humans like us?

The supreme Lord Sri Krishna, treats him with the strongest medicine - Atma jnAna. The foundation for the Vedic nyAya (justice) and dharma (morality or duty) is jnAna.

What is jnAna? - Knowing the difference and the relation between body and soul/self is jnAna. Ishwara or Brahman is paramAtma - ultimate indwelling and all pervading Self supporting the entire universe consisting of jiva and jada as his body (as it were).

Body is that which is supported, controlled and used by the self/atman. Body is always at the service of the self/soul and the needs of the body is taken care by the self. Similarly the jiva is the body or servant of Ishwara/Brahman who is the inner supporter/controller and protector. This is true jnAna.

Every entity jiva/jada in the world is different. But the fact that the same Brahman is present in all, is the greatest equalizer. True equanimity arises only when the same Ishwara/God is SEEN in all.

What is ajnAna? - Identification of the self/atma with the body. Looking only at the body of oneself and others and not seeing the atman-parmAtman. This is ajnAna - the root of all problems

What is ViparIta jnAna? To identify oneself as Svatantra or God/Ishwara. (This is Asuri bhAva which is explicitly taught in B.Gita 16-14. This is even more dangerous than ajnyAna.


Secret 2-1 - God as the spirit Self of the universe is singular and plural at the same time. Advaita, Dvaita and V.Advaita are like different snanna ghattas leading to the same Ganga of Brahman/God. 

B.Gita 2-12
न त्वेवाहं जातु नासं न त्वं नेमे जनाधिपाः ।
न चैव न भविष्यामः सर्वे वयमतः परम् ॥ १२ ॥

na tv evaham jatu nasam
na tvam neme janadhipah
na caiva na bhavisyamah
sarve vayam atah param

na—never; tu—but; eva—certainly; aham—I; jatu—become; na—never; asam—existed; na—it is not so; tvam—yourself; na—not; ime—all these; janadhipah—kings; na—never; ca—also; eva—certainly; na—not like that; bhavisyamah—shall exist; sarve—all of us; vayam—we; atah param—hereafter.

There was no time when I (Ishwara or God) was not there and so are you (devotee) and all these rulers (many jivas). We will never cease to exist and continue to exist in future.

This proves the continued existence of Ishwara and all the many jivas. This seems to be explicitly supporting Dvaita / V.Advaita and may appear as a hard nut to crack for Advaita. But it is not! 

The word "वयम्" (vayam - US) is the SECRET that reconciles all views. The universal Self or the all pervading Brahman is singular and plural at the same time as all plurality exist in that.

The reality of the universe as the body of Brahman who pervades and indwells in it as the supreme Self/Atman satisfies all views.

Just like infinite grains of rice along with their plants are potentially present in a SINGLE grain of rice, the entire universe with countless jivas and jada can potentially exist in ONE Brahman.

Objection:  If Brahman is non-dual how can it be many?

Answer: Though it is one, out of its own mysterious power of mAya it takes birth and becomes many and manifests as this universe. In the purusha sUkta it is explicitly stated "AjAyamAno bahudA vijAyate" - "though unborn he takes many birth". There is one in many and many in one! This Vedantic view alone can unite the otherwise diverse world.

Secret 2-2 - The relationship between atman/jiva and paramAtman/Ishwara is similar to the body and soul.

If Brahman is the inner ultimate Self or paramAtma then obviously the world consisting of jiva and jada are in the position of the body. This is explicitly taught in the B.Gita 13-1 and 2.

This is also explicitly taught in the AntaryAmi brAhmaNa of BrihadAraNyaka upanishad.
"Atmano antaroyamAtmA na veda yasa AtmA SharIram.

The body always serves the soul. The atman therefore is a servant of parmAtman manifesting as this very universe. So service to universe = service to God. Therefore nothing can go wrong in identifying oneself as a servant. Ceaseless service to others is sanAtana dharma.


Secret 2-3 - True atma jnyAni alone can engage in svadharma without fear or favor. The golden rule of morality - "to treat others as oneself would like to be treated" - has its basis in Atma jnana.

The atman in all the many bodies are eternal. That which kills or get killed is the body. The body is an instrument through which the atman can engage in svadharma. The nature svadharma depends upon the nature of the body. It does not matter what kind of service or job that one does as long as it is discharged as a service to the world/God. The nature or svaroopa of an atman is to serve. True ananda is in service only.

"ParOpakArArthamidam shareeram" - The only purpose of the body is to serve others.

Good people serve others by torturing/sacrificing/destroying themselves while bad jivas serve themselves by torturing/sacrificing/destroying others. But the svadharma of a kshatriya is to protect the good and destroy the evil even if the perpetrators of evil are his own kith and kin. He is supposed to ignore bodily relations and the resulting mamakAra. If this goes out of control then God descends down to restore balance.


B.Gita 2.26
अथ चैनं नित्यजातं नित्यं वा मन्यसे मृतम् ।
तथापि त्वं महाबाहो नैवं शोचितुमर्हसि ॥ २६ ॥

atha cainam nitya-jatam
nityam va manyase mrtam
tathapi tvam maha-baho
nainam socitum arhasi

atha—if, however; ca—also; enam—this soul; nitya-jatam—always born; nityam—forever; va—either; manyase—so you think; mrtam—dead; tathapi—even then ; tvam—you; maha-baho—O mighty-armed one; na—never; enam—about such a soul; socitum—to lament; arhasi—deserve.


Secret 2-4 - Dharma will still be sanAtana or eternal even if atman is identified with the body which is continuously going through changes / birth and death.

How is this possible?

The golden rule of morality still holds good even if the self is identified with the body that constantly undergoes change or birth/death. How? By looking upon the entire universe as God on whom every being/body/self depends. The dependence of oneself/body on the family, society and universe cannot be ruled out by any sane person even if he is an atheist. So there is a need to return back the favor by engaging in dharma / self less service.

It is also a fact that the world/society is made of good (sattvic), bad (tamasic) and in-between (rajasic) entities. Therefore there is always a need to eliminate/control the evil/bad and protect the good to sustain harmony in the society.

It is also interesting to note that the eternity of atman also gets indirectly established as it always remains a witness for the changing body and the world. Atman as the seer of change cannot change. Every jiva likes to exist for ever and no being would like to die or suffer. This doubtlessly indicates that atman is essentially eternal!

So Sri Krishna is motivating Arjuna not to shirk from duty/dharma of eliminating evil, even if it is perpetrated by his own relatives.


B.Gita - 2.41

व्यवसायात्मिका बुद्धिरेकेह कुरुनन्दन ।
बहुशाखा ह्यनन्ताश्च बुद्धयोऽव्यवसायिनाम् ॥ ४१ ॥

vyavasayatmika buddhir
ekeha kuru-nandana
bahu-sakha hy anantas ca
buddhayo 'vyavasayinam

vyavasayatmika—resolute consciousness of realities and God; buddhih—intelligence; eka—only one; iha—in this world; kuru-nandana—O beloved child of the Kurus; bahu-sakhah—various branches; hi—indeed; anantah—endless; ca—also; buddhayah—intelligence; avyavasayinam—of those who are not in conscious of all pervading God.

Vyavasaya literally means agriculture where there is a need to remove the weeds and care for the right crop. Similarly in dharma there is need to remove evil and nurture good and all these have to be done without fear or favor as a service to Brahman.

VyavasAyAtmikA buddhi is the perfect alignment of thoughts words and deeds always directed towards the service of Brahman manifesting as this very universe. Such people always see that one Brahman alone in all the many varieties.

Those who do not see the same divine God in all the many entities in the universe will be bewildered by all the many material varieties made of the three gunas. They will not be able to discharge duties in an impartial manner.

Secret 2-5: No job is high or low. Every job is sacred when it culminates as a service to that ONE God manifesting as the Society/World. 

Namaste
Suresh


Saturday, April 25, 2020

Bhagavad Gita - Hidden Secrets - 1

Theme : Vishada or despondency as a yoga.


Namaste,


Bhagavad Gita has many secrets. Infact every sloka in the B.Gita could reveal many secrets or hidden meanings. 

Here is the first and the most important open secret:

Secret 1-1:

"Bhagavad Gita is the only shAstra or scripture in the world that was given directly by Bhagavan / the Supreme God to humans through Arjuna". 

No other scripture in the world enjoys this position. This fact should make every true Hindu proud.

In the Vedic Hindu religion God himself follows what He preaches. The entire universe is His manifestation. In the form the universe He is teaching sanAtana dharma to all true humans. How? Every entity in nature is giving itself for others. Earth, water, fire and so on are engaging in their respective service according to their nature.

Humans are thus encouraged to just follow the same by engaging in their svadharma according to their nature! sanAtana Dharma is thus eternal and everliving.

Anything that goes against the above leads to ajnyAna or ignorance which is the root of all problems.


Here are some more interesting secrets from the first chapter – Arjuna Vishada yoga:

1. Our own body is a Dharmakshetra and Kurukshetra

2. Vishada  could be a yoga or means to attain God.

3. One should realize that he is afflicted with Vishada

4. One should not analyze and conclude while in that confused state.

5. There is a need to share vishada and voluntarily surrender to an able AchArya like Sri Krishna.

who is in a better or higher position to .

6. Similar to Vishada- dharma Himsa is also a yoga.


vishAda in Sanskrit means:

dejection, depression, despondency, dullness, stupidity, insensibility, fear, weakness

There is no doubt that vishAda is something that is negative. Yoga in the spiritual context is the process of union with God.

Q: Positive practices like jnyAna and Bhakti could be a yoga. But how could vishAda be a yoga? Or what makes it a yoga?

A: 
vishAda will never be a yoga if the person is alone. Anyone going through vishAda must seek advice from another person, like a Parent, Guru, Acharya or even a friend who are in a better or higher position. If the other person is in a lower or even in a equal position we may unnecessarily disturb them or our own vishada may increase. Safest person to surrender is one’s own Guru or Acharya.

Q: Arjuna was lucky as he had the Lord Krishna himself with whom he could share his vishAda. But what about ordinary humans like us?

A: Vedas teach that the Jiva and Ishwara are two birds in the same body/tree. So no jiva is spiritually alone. Lord Krishna / Ishwara is present in all completely.  

This Ishwara is also everywhere. Infact the entire universe is Ishwara’s body. When we realize this, we can easily start feeling the presence of Ishwara and share or surrender our everything to Him.

Dharma kshetra is the place where dharma is performed. Kuru in Sanskrit means ‘to do karma or actions’. Every sane human has the ability to do dharma (selfless service and adharma/karma (selfish actions). So, our own body could be dharma kshetra or kuru kshetra (accumulating adharma/karma).

Pandavas had seven akshauhini (about one hundred thousand) warriors and kauravas had eleven. These numbers have spiritual or philosophical significance. The entire universe of five elements along with Ishwara and jiva are totally seven. These are the pandavas.

The jiva’s body has eleven organs: 

1. Five jnana indriyas through which we get knowledge – eyes, nose, ears, tongue and skin (touch).

2. Five karma indriyas through which we do action – hands, legs, speech, excretory and genital organs. 

3. One mind.

When we do not recognize Ishwara / God manifesting as the universe then we will end up looking upon the universe as mere object for sense gratification. We thus end up as kauravas using our eleven senses fighting against the God/universe.

On the other hand when we recognize God manifesting in the form of the universe, we will be aligning our personality with it and end up using our eleven sense organs in the service of the universe / God. When Iswara thus enters our personality, he manifests in eleven forms of Rudra in us.

The solution for any problem does not lie in the same dimension as the problem. It will always come from a higher dimension. Arjuna tried to analyze the problem and conclude while still engulfed in vishAda and so was dejected at the end of the first chapter of BGita.

But later in the BG:2-7, he surrendered himself completely to Krishna always at the higher dimension. We need to do the same thing for every problem we encounter in our lives.

Word to word meaning of related B.Gita slokas:

(Source: www.asitis.com)

BG 1:1

dhrtarastrah—King Dhrtarastra; uvaca—said; dharma-kshetre—in the sacred place righteousness; kuru-ksetre—in the place named Kuruksetra; samavetah—assembled; yuyatsavah—warriors desiring to fight; mamakah—my sons; pandavah—the sons of Pandu; ca—and; eva-certainly; kim—what; akurvata—did they do; sanjaya—O Sanjaya.


TRANSLATION

Dhrtarastra said: O Sanjaya, after assembling in the place of righteousness at Kuruksetra, what did my sons and the sons of Pandu do, being desirous to fight?


BG 1:46

sanjayah—Sanjaya; uvaca—said; evam—thus; uktva—saying; arjunah—Arjuna; sankhye—in the battlefield; ratha—chariot; upasthah—situated on; upavisat—sat down again; visrjya—keeping aside; sa-saram—along with arrows; capam—the bow; soka—lamentation; samvigna—distressed; manasah—within the mind.


TRANSLATION

Sanjaya said: Arjuna, having thus spoken on the battlefield, cast aside his bow and arrows and sat down on the chariot, his mind overwhelmed with grief.

BG 2:47

karpanya—miserly; dosa—weakness; upahata—being inflicted by; svabhavah—characteristics; prcchami—I am asking; tvam—unto You; dharma—religion; sammudha—bewildered; cetah—in heart; yat—what; sreyah—all-good; syat—may be; niscitam—confidently; bruhi—tell; tat—that; me—unto me; sisyah—disciple; te—Your; aham—I am; sadhi—just instruct; mam—me; tvam—unto You; prapannam—surrendered.

TRANSLATION

Now I am confused about my duty and have lost all composure because of weakness. In this condition I am asking You to tell me clearly what is best for me. Now I am Your disciple, and a soul surrendered unto You. Please instruct me.


Namaste
Suresh

Tuesday, April 14, 2020

Is the world of samsAra, a problem?

Generally in the religious circles it is believed that the samsAra or the
world is full of problems. So it needs to be shunned or avoided. The ultimate
aim is to go to the God's world or heaven, which is always perfect.

This may be true apparently. But is it really so? In my humble opinion, it all
depends on how one SEES the world.

For some (buddhists and advaitins), the world is not real, just an illusion.
For some (dvaitins and V.Advaitins) the world though real, is undesirable.
For some (atheists?), it may appear that the world is "just out there" by
sheer accident!. Some others may feel that the world won't care for them and
they don't care either. Many views are possible.

But the individual perception of the world has nothing to do with what the
world really is.

According to the Vedas the entire world is a manifestation of God. "Purusham
evEdagm sarvam" (everything is Purusha) , "Sarvam khalvidam brahma (every-
thing is Brahman) and so on explicitly state that. It is also a fact that all beings
are absolutely dependent on the world it for existence.

It is also a fact that from the body point of view, we all are IN THE WORLD.
We derive our existence from the world. All of our so called possessions
belong to the world. We as embodied individuals, are born in, exist / subsist
and return back to the world of elements only.

There seems to be no selfishness in the world. Everything like food, air,
water are given to us for free. So the ideal for humans is to mimic the same.
The world will work with us if we work with it. But the same world would
oppose us when we oppose it.

Yes, the world would be a problem if we look upon it as a mere object of
sense enjoyment. But the same world would turn out to be a solution or the
source of true happiness when we look upon it as a manifestation of God and
engage in selfless service.

All do's and don'ts, good and bad when defined from the individual point of
view would be different and conflicting. But when the same when defined from
the point of view of the world, it will always be universal and aligns with all.

As per the Veda, the world as a whole is the body of God and so service to the
world is service to God. This is the real essence of Vedic scriptures / dharma.
Unlike other individual views, this Vedic view can stand by itself as it is defined
from the point of view of the world which is common to all.

Probably that is the reason why it is called apourusheya or impersonal!??
Interestingly, when the entire world is realized as the personality of God, then
that which is impersonal ends up as extremely personal!!

The seer alone SEES!

Namaste
Suresh